A strangulation charge in a Bronx domestic violence case is one of the most aggressively prosecuted offenses in New York criminal law. New York law creates three separate strangulation offenses under Penal Law Article 121, ranging from a Class A misdemeanor to a Class C violent felony. Each carries vastly different consequences, and even an accusation can upend your life, your housing, and your family before any verdict is reached.
Bronx domestic violence lawyer David Mejia Colgan, Esq., represents clients facing strangulation charges in domestic violence cases in Bronx Criminal Court and Bronx Supreme Court. A former prosecutor in the Bronx County District Attorney’s Office, he has more than 25 years of criminal law experience and understands how the DA’s Domestic Violence Bureau investigates and builds these cases.
This page explains all three strangulation offenses under PL § 121.11, PL § 121.12, and PL § 121.13, along with how Bronx prosecutors build these cases, what penalties a conviction carries, and what defense strategies apply. Call David Mejia Colgan, Esq. at (718) 484-8820 for a free and confidential review of your case.
The best lawyer in New York City, personally highly recommended and I would hire him again if necessary. He dissolved my attempted murder case and reduced it to public…
New York Penal Law Article 121 establishes three standalone strangulation offenses, enacted in 2010. The statute covers both strangulation (external pressure on the neck or throat) and obstruction of breathing (blocking the nose or mouth). All three offenses arise frequently in domestic violence cases across the Bronx, where the Bronx DA’s Domestic Violence Bureau handles prosecution.
Criminal Obstruction of Breathing or Blood Circulation under PL § 121.11 is the baseline Article 121 offense. A person commits this crime by intentionally impeding another person’s normal breathing or blood circulation by applying pressure to the throat or neck, or by blocking the nose or mouth. No physical injury is required. As a Class A misdemeanor, a conviction carries up to 364 days in jail, probation, community service, or a combination of these penalties.
Strangulation in the Second Degree under PL § 121.12 elevates the offense to a Class D violent felony. The prosecution must prove the same conduct as § 121.11, plus an aggravating result: stupor, loss of consciousness for any period of time, or any other physical injury or impairment. Physical signs such as red marks on the neck, petechiae (burst blood vessels in the eyes or face), and voice changes often influence the DA’s decision to charge § 121.12 instead of the misdemeanor. A conviction carries a determinate sentence of 2 to 7 years in state prison with mandatory post-release supervision.
Strangulation in the First Degree under PL § 121.13 is the most severe charge, classified as a Class C violent felony. The prosecution must prove that the defendant’s conduct caused serious physical injury, a significantly higher threshold than ordinary physical injury. A conviction carries a determinate sentence of 3.5 to 15 years in state prison. Our dedicated page on first-degree strangulation covers this charge in greater detail, including how Bronx prosecutors establish the serious physical injury element.
The table below summarizes all three offenses, with each tier distinguished by the required level of injury and the resulting sentencing exposure.
| Offense | Statute | Classification | Key Element | Sentence Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Criminal Obstruction of Breathing | PL § 121.11 | Class A Misdemeanor | Intentional obstruction of breathing or blood circulation | Up to 1 year in jail |
| Strangulation, Second Degree | PL § 121.12 | Class D Violent Felony | Obstruction causing stupor, loss of consciousness, or physical injury | 2 to 7 years in prison |
| Strangulation, First Degree | PL § 121.13 | Class C Violent Felony | Obstruction causing serious physical injury | 3.5 to 15 years in prison |
Key Takeaway: New York’s three strangulation offenses range from a Class A misdemeanor (PL § 121.11) to a Class C violent felony (PL § 121.13). The degree charged depends primarily on whether, and how seriously, the victim was physically injured.
Call David Mejia Colgan, Esq. at (718) 484-8820 for a confidential review of your case.
I reside in Florida however my son needed a criminal attorney in New York. A family attorney researched and recommended David for the job. I was skeptical at first but…
Elite Representation, Personal Attention, Proven Results
Work Directly With David Colgan: 24/7, Start to Finish
The distinction between second-degree and first-degree strangulation often comes down to a single question: how severe were the victim’s injuries? Under PL § 10.00(9), “physical injury” means impairment of physical condition or substantial pain. Under PL § 10.00(10), ‘serious physical injury’ means physical injury that creates a substantial risk of death, causes death, causes serious and protracted disfigurement, causes protracted impairment of health, or causes protracted loss or impairment of the function of any bodily organ.
In Bronx strangulation cases, prosecutors rely on medical records, SANE (Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner) findings, and emergency room documentation to establish which threshold applies. When imaging reveals a hyoid bone fracture, extensive petechiae, or other serious medical findings, prosecutors may consider a PL § 121.13 charge, depending on whether the evidence supports the statutory definition of serious physical injury.
Petechiae (burst blood vessels in the eyes and face) are a hallmark sign frequently cited in Bronx domestic violence strangulation prosecutions. CT scans, SANE examinations, ER notes, and photographs taken at different intervals all serve as prosecution evidence.
911 recordings may be offered under hearsay exceptions, such as the excited-utterance exception, even if the complainant later recants or refuses to cooperate, but admissibility depends on the facts and the judge’s ruling. Testimony from neighbors, statements from children present in the home, and observations by responding officers all strengthen the prosecution’s case. Bronx prosecutors in the DA’s Domestic Violence Bureau are trained to build cases using this evidence independently of victim participation.
Key Takeaway: Prosecutors in the Bronx use medical records, 911 recordings, and witness statements to establish injury severity, even when visible marks are absent. The difference between a PL § 121.12 and PL § 121.13 charge often comes down to a single medical finding.
Call (718) 484-8820 to discuss the evidence in your strangulation case with David Mejia Colgan, Esq.
I am immensely grateful for David who is the go-to-guy for my entire family! His unwavering dedication, legal prowess, and genuine compassion have not only…
The prosecution must prove every element of the charge beyond a reasonable doubt. In the Bronx, misdemeanor cases are tried in Bronx Criminal Court, while felonies proceed in Bronx Supreme Court. The required elements differ by degree:
Intent is a critical element across all three tiers. If the conduct was accidental, it does not satisfy the statute. The prosecution must also prove the specific manner of obstruction, whether by pressure to the neck or by blocking the nose or mouth.
No. Bronx prosecutors in the DA’s Domestic Violence Bureau frequently proceed without victim cooperation using the “evidence-based prosecution” model. This approach may rely on 911 recordings, medical records, admissible statements, photographs, and physical evidence. Additionally, any attempt by the defendant to intimidate the witness can result in separate criminal charges.
A conviction on any strangulation charge carries penalties that extend well beyond the courtroom. Sentencing depends on the degree of the offense, the defendant’s criminal history, and whether the conviction qualifies as a violent felony under PL § 70.02.
The sentencing ranges for each offense are as follows:
A prior violent felony conviction significantly increases sentencing exposure under New York’s second violent felony offender provisions, raising mandatory minimums and limiting judicial discretion. Defendants with prior violent felony records face elevated mandatory minimum terms and reduced opportunities for judicial leniency at sentencing.
Even a PL § 121.11 misdemeanor conviction carries lasting consequences for Bronx residents long after any jail sentence ends, including effects on employment, housing, immigration status, and family court proceedings.
Key Takeaway: A strangulation conviction in New York, even at the misdemeanor level, carries consequences far beyond jail time, including immigration jeopardy, firearm prohibitions, and barriers to employment and housing.
Call David Mejia Colgan, Esq. at (718) 484-8820 before the stakes get higher.
I reside in Florida however my son needed a criminal attorney in New York. A family attorney researched and recommended David for the job. I was skeptical at first but…
Elite Representation, Personal Attention, Proven Results
Work Directly With a Criminal Defense Lawyer
David Mejia Colgan, Esq. has dedicated more than 25 years to criminal law, with a focus on domestic violence cases. He graduated from New York University School of Law in 1998. Attorney Colgan began his career as an Assistant District Attorney in the Bronx County District Attorney’s Office, where he served in the domestic violence and sex crimes bureaus and prosecuted serious felony matters, including homicides. He is admitted to practice in New York State and in the U.S. District Courts for the Southern, Eastern, Northern, and Western Districts of New York.
David Mejia Colgan’s years in the Bronx DA’s Office mean he has seen how the Domestic Violence Bureau investigates, charges, and tries strangulation cases firsthand. His approach centers on reviewing all evidence, including medical records, 911 recordings, and witness statements, to identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case before trial. Fluent in Spanish, David Mejia Colgan works closely with the Bronx’s Spanish-speaking communities, making sure his clients fully understand the legal process and their options.
Strangulation cases in the Bronx begin at arraignment in Bronx Criminal Court, where a judge sets bail and issues an order of protection. The Bronx District Attorney’s Office has a dedicated Domestic Violence Bureau that prosecutes felony strangulation charges under PL § 121.12 and PL § 121.13. Misdemeanor cases under PL § 121.11 may be handled in a specialized domestic violence court part.
The DA typically requests remand or high bail in strangulation cases because courts treat them as high-lethality domestic violence situations. An order of protection is almost always issued at this first appearance, often requiring the defendant to stay away from the complainant entirely. If the defendant and complainant share a home, this means immediate displacement from the residence.
Two main types of orders of protection apply in the Bronx. A “full stay away” order prohibits all contact with the complainant, including phone calls, texts, emails, and messages through third parties. A “refrain from” order allows contact but prohibits threatening, harassing, or intimidating behavior. Both types are enforceable the moment they are issued.
Violating either type of order is charged as Criminal Contempt. This is often pursued as a misdemeanor (PL § 215.50), but can quickly be escalated to a separate felony (PL § 215.51) depending on prior convictions or if the violation involved violence or harassment. Both the criminal court and family court can issue orders of protection in domestic violence cases.
First I have to say David is god sent and very professional. I was in an impossible seat to face up to 5 years in prison I hired David to make that less and he did what nobody…
Learn More
Every strangulation defense targets one or more elements the prosecution must prove: intent, the act of obstruction, the level of injury, or the credibility of the allegations. The right strategy depends entirely on the facts and evidence in each case.
False or exaggerated allegations do occur in strangulation cases, particularly in the context of custody disputes, relationship breakdowns, or situations where the complainant seeks housing or immigration advantages. Inconsistencies between the complainant’s statements at different points (to police, to medical staff, in 911 calls) can significantly undermine the prosecution’s case. A thorough defense investigation may include reviewing text messages, social media posts, surveillance footage, and communications that contradict the complainant’s account.
Under Penal Law Article 35, a person may use physical force when they reasonably believe it is necessary to defend against imminent unlawful physical force. Once the defense raises a justification, the prosecution bears the burden of disproving it beyond a reasonable doubt. In situations involving mutual physical confrontation, the identity of the initial aggressor becomes a central issue.
Injuries attributed to strangulation can sometimes have alternative explanations. Petechiae, for example, may result from forceful coughing, vomiting, or preexisting medical conditions. Bruising may stem from consensual contact or unrelated incidents. A defense-retained medical professional can review SANE findings and emergency room records, then present alternative explanations that raise reasonable doubt about the prosecution’s theory.
Key Takeaway: The strongest defenses to strangulation charges often center on challenging intent, contesting the source or severity of injuries, or exposing inconsistencies and motives behind the allegations. Each case depends on its specific facts and evidence.
Call (718) 484-8820 for a confidential consultation with David Mejia Colgan, Esq. to review the defense options in your case.
David Mejia Colgan, Esq. represents clients facing strangulation and domestic violence charges throughout the Bronx, including Fordham, Mott Haven, Hunts Point, Kingsbridge, Highbridge, University Heights, Tremont, Morris Park, and Pelham Bay. Our office at 910 Grand Concourse, Suite 1F, also serves clients in courts across New York City and throughout New York State.
24/7 Access, Flat Fees, Bilingual Service – David Handles Everything Personally
A strangulation charge can affect every part of your life, from where you sleep tonight to whether you can see your children. David Mejia Colgan, Esq., a Bronx domestic violence lawyer and a former prosecutor in the Bronx DA’s Office, handles strangulation cases prosecuted by the Domestic Violence Bureau.
Our team understands how these cases are built and where evidence can be challenged.
Call (718) 484-8820 for a confidential consultation with David Mejia Colgan, Esq.
The decision to prosecute belongs to the Bronx District Attorney. Prosecutors in the DA’s Domestic Violence Bureau can and do proceed using 911 recordings, medical evidence, and witness statements, even when the complainant recants or refuses to cooperate. Victims do not control the charging decision once an arrest has been made.
Strangulation offenses under Penal Law Article 121 are standalone charges separate from assault under Penal Law Article 120. A defendant can be charged with both strangulation and assault arising from the same incident, with each carrying its own penalties. The strangulation statutes were enacted specifically to address the lethality of neck compression in domestic violence situations.
No. Criminal Obstruction of Breathing or Blood Circulation under PL § 121.11 is a Class A misdemeanor. However, Strangulation in the Second Degree (PL § 121.12) and Strangulation in the First Degree (PL § 121.13) are both classified as violent felonies. Even a misdemeanor conviction under PL § 121.11 carries collateral consequences, including potential immigration impact.
That depends on the type of order issued. A “full stay away” order typically prohibits returning to a shared residence. A “refrain from” order may allow you to remain in the home but prohibits threatening or harassing behavior. The specific terms are set by the judge at arraignment in Bronx Criminal Court, and violating an order of protection can result in separate criminal contempt charges, and some violations can be charged as felonies.
A violent felony conviction under PL § 121.12 or PL § 121.13 can be classified as an aggravated felony under federal immigration law, which may trigger removal proceedings. Even a misdemeanor conviction under PL § 121.11 can create immigration complications. Non-citizen defendants should discuss immigration consequences with David Mejia Colgan, Esq. before resolving any charge.
